Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Don Midwest's avatar

Another excellent article.

Reading the first part on railroads, I reflected to 2011 when the newly elected Republicans governors of Ohio and Florida cancelled federal funds for high speed rail in their state.

Then as I read on and on of the plans and ongoing progress in Russia, I reflected that when I graduated HS in 1960 there was a similar wide open field of options. And optimism. Maybe it was Sputnik that shook the US out of its self assurance, but in any case there was a lot of progress and hope.

The US also successfully scrapped the rail they had in cities like LA and continued to go with the distributed transportation system which led years ago to 10% of the land in Los Angeles was used for freeways and fleets of delivery trucks where there could have been rail for freight.

And that is just comparing Russia and US from the first part of the article.

Then the article goes on and on about progress and plans. And the president is engaged. And the focus is on self sufficiency and supporting people.

Given the US political situation, and the real power in finance and Big Business, what is described here is impossible in the US. Which means that not only can we not understand Russia because it is evil, or something, but the US will continue to decline relative to other countries and it is already declining compared to itself. But we have defeated socialism!!! Hooray for us!!! Look at our medical system to see what private enterprise can do!! We are heading for 20% of GDP on health care for a sick society!!

Expand full comment
Gerrard White's avatar

22 December 2023 Karlof1 Russian development Meeting of the Council for strategic development and National projects

This is even more important than your regular reports and document/meeting transcriptions & translations, which are already many times more informative than documents or figures referred to/quoted in the non Russian press or media

You mention there are other meetings planned, the one on the Artic would be crucial

The long term planning docs 40-50 pages you could not post! But some western based 'Russia Council' should construct a library of such

But all you already publish gives the lie to the facile what passes for reporting in the western press, Russia is bankrupt and so on – the Sonnenfeld syndrome

Is (are) there anyone anywhere who has produced overall and precise and sourced figures for industrial production by sector, for armaments production, for labour rates and wage increases by sector, for imports and exports, and so on?

Once again mes hommages, you are an essential worker

PS One quibble: the opening statement

‘Our railway network ranks first in the world in terms of usage, providing 87 percent of the country's cargo turnover and about a third of passenger traffic.

can not be true, surely India must have more railways passengers

PPS The Year of the Family and the various programs to foster larger families have been the butt of much scorn in the woken west – but, coming from a continent where large families are still the norm, one can say that this is extremely significant

That the social systems developed by large families, the accrued importance and authority of the family, the clans which develop in parallel, and consequent notions of autonomy and multiple sources of authority provides a radically different (and ‘larger’) view of the world, one in which ‘individualism’ is rendered mute

Compared to miserable fate of declining populations etc etc, South Korea e.g., and now a panic in England about the drastic decline in native birthrate towards extinction

Expand full comment
25 more comments...

No posts