Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Richard Roskell's avatar

Good comments Karl. Of course every nation should condemn Israel's genocide. However I'm not sure they all will.

The USA: obviously not. The USA will condemn and threaten those who made the determination.

Canada and Britain: will not condemn Israel, but may make noises along the lines of, "Israel must abide by humanitarian law."

The EU: ditto. Some nations like Germany and Hungary may actually renew support for Israel.

China: will most likely restate its condemnation of Israel's actions, while possibly taking other steps behind the scenes.

Russia: likely to be a tepid response, certainly nothing that reflects the gravity of genocide.

There's a very big problem with how nations approach the issue of genocide. Yes, just about everyone's on board with the Convention and they say the performative things. But actually coming to grips with genocide when it happens, and acknowledging the genocides of the past including their own, is another thing entirely.

There are very few nations of the Collective West that HAVEN'T committed genocide (as it's defined in the Convention) at some point in their histories. My nation of Canada ethnically cleansed and committed genocide against the aboriginal First Nations people who lived here first. The USA did the same. The Spaniards raped and pillaged the New World top to bottom. The Dutch raped and pillaged Africa and SE Asia. Portugal the same. France likewise. They all know they're guilty of genocide, some quite recently in historical terms. And not one, not a single one (other than Germany and just for the Holocaust) has admitted their guilt. Therefore they have no basis on which to take a moral stand against Israel. So they don't.

The nations of the world that don't have a history of rapacious colonizing are, I'm sure, quite willing to condemn Israel for its genocide. But all the other colonizers and aggressors will offer little criticism. They've known full well that Israel's genocide has been going on for two years, and they've just watched. A UN report calling it genocide is unlikely to make them take serious steps.

Though I will be happy to be proven wrong.

Expand full comment
Grasshopper Kaplan's avatar

Yes .

I have noticed DonDon is quick to decry so-called Russian aggression against UkroNam, while he never whispers what hath Isra Hell wrought.

Sadly. I learned the price for speaking out a tiny bit was solitary isolation and jail, thank you ScKamala Harris.

Genocide is all America knows....

Expand full comment
64 more comments...

No posts