Discussion about this post

User's avatar
bevin's avatar

The "West" doesn't have any values- it lost them all in adopting capitalism and imperialism, both forms of naked exploitation and looting. Then it tried to cover it up by developing, with the eager co-operation of institutions which had been built by remembering to 'render unto Caesar" what they were told to render, the sort of organised hypocrisy that is recalled as Victorianism.

Actually the Bolsheviks and socialism in general were a reaction against the demolition of values, such as human solidarity, neighbourliness and mutual aid, promoted by the first class society that insisted on total submission. Feudalism, much abused and ill remembered, had no conception of private property rights trumping social claims- the land belonged to the people.

To link the imperialists' desecration of bssic human values with the Bolsheviks is not just cheap demagogy- a crass appeal to fascist and reactionary opinion- but a misrepresentation of some of the idealistic flourishes that accompanied a social revolution which allowed free expression after generations of authoritarian clerical and state repression.

To argue for a free sexual community is not to impose it- there was never a chance that "women would be communalised " (one of the oldest slanders in the book of lies) simply a brief period in which people were allowed to express their ideas, however weird or perverse.

The objection to the idiocies of currently fashionable 'woke' dogmas is that they are designed to distract and obscure at a time when reality is becoming so simple as to be undeniable. It is another form of Victorianism, the other side of the coin and is born of the insistence that 'up ' is 'down' and transparency is opaque. It is an old bag of tricks- we saw it in full evidence during the Epstein hysteria when all the world was telling itself that young women were unattractive to all but perverts unless they had celebrated their eighteenth birthdays. Everyone knew it to be nonsense- men knew it, girls knew it- but nobody dared to emulate Major de Coverley and call it out.

The value that is missing is that of honesty- truth telling. Our society has been corrupted by setting out to anticipate the wishes of our rulers and earn their patronage by singing the songs that please them. What is called education is clearly indoctrination in what we are supposed to pretend to believe.

That the latest idea is to pretend to believe that men can become pregnant or that men dressed in women's clothing are emblems of wisdom is no more surprising than the idea that vaccines should be sold for profit rather than used to suppress disease or that children should be left to die of hunger unless they are wealthy or that Oil Companies should be allowed to pollute the planet , despite the interests of billions born and unborn.

It was one of the great discoveries of the critics of early capitalism that all that they valued in the world was endangered by the worship of Mammon (as our old friend puts it) and that the "new" ideas of the liberals and the political economists were radical uprootings of all that was worthy of conserving as a basis for development. To return to the values that they cherished, whether in sectarian religious forms or in the simple secular practises of humans treating each other decently, involves not just a turning from the more exotic ideological emanations of a sick society but a demolition of a social system built upon private ownership of the means whereby we make our living.

Expand full comment
Davy Ro's avatar

Russia is morally head & shoulders above all western nations. It's total insanity the way my own country & the other Western nations are heading. Russia is showing the most rational way for a decent future.

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts