If Vasily Kashin's analysis seems to me interesting and in certain aspects clarifying, your commentary on it seems even more interesting. From it I extract two quotes that I consider significant:
(1) “The forever wars that were sparked by the 911 false flag have bankrupted the federal government, although they’ve certainly aided the Zionists who helped plan it.”
The weight of Zionism in the domestic and foreign policy of the Outlaw US Empire has been and remains decisive. The support of the powerful lobby for Trump is not unconditional, nor does it have MAGA politics as a priority. The lobby will do everything in its power to establish the priorities of the Empire according to its own interests.
(2) “What Europe needs is a return of “left” political parties to confront the EU-Globalists: There’s plenty of room for a Nationalist Left to fill the current political vacuum.”
One of the main missions entrusted to the CIA after the Second World War was precisely the destruction of the European left, specifically its then powerful communist parties, most of which were pro-Soviet. In Spain, but especially in Italy, this clandestine anti-communist struggle reached authentic terrorist levels on the part of the CIA. Today we can see that it was not so much about fighting communism as about keeping Europe separated from the USSR, that is, from Russia.
The problem of the Outlaw US Empire is the same, or similar, to that of a huge oil tanker: both to dock and to set sail properly, the tanker needs the support of tugboats to support and correct the force of its enormous inertia. These "tugboats" are called Diplomacy and reliability: the Outlaw US Empire has lost both.
"the world's best geographical location, a huge domestic market, high resource endowments, developed industry and the world's largest technological potential."
Only the second item is true. But is worthless if that domestic market can't afford even the basics.
The third is correct; high but not huge compared to Russia for example.
Yeah, I didn’t want to call him out on too many of his errs. I see the Canadians are standing up and pushing back as well. Many of those resources are gone, extracted already. And as with the 1890s Plutocrats, today’s have no need for industry when their rents pay so much.
For some time I've been struggling to understand what is meant by 'left' and 'right' in governance.
'Left', for me, means comprehensive welfare government. A government entrusted with providing welfare for all its people: ensuring that everyone, whether individual, in family, community, or distinctive social sector receives what they need to live well, and isn't deprived of any of these goods. This is not impossible. In Britain after the war we built a welfare state through public services, which has only been demolished through neoliberal Thatcher's reign. China has built it over the past 40-odd years years. The ideological manifesto of left is based on "Help each other out, don't do each other down". Internationally pursuing mutual sovereign respect, cooperation and friendliness. Unfortunately disregarding sovereign internal ethnofascist social institutions of inequality. National evils are none of our business.
'Right', I find more difficult to comprehend. It seems to follow the injunction: "fight each other". Divide and rule so that the identified distinctive social group strives to win against the excluded rest. It embodies ethnofascism: we, the privileged people, rule, punish (corporally and capitally), and deprive you, the unworthy. And we practice 'keep-rule'. National Securities R Us.
In national and international behaviour, 'right' comprises the intention and practise of mortal belligerence of the putative ruling group towards everybody else. Wherever in the world mutualist, socialist governance has emerged and been effective, the Anglo-American Imperialists have destroyed it, more than 50 times since the Second World War. Recently, it seems, mutualist governance has begun surviving the viral rabidity of rightist global forces.
I'd be interested in others' characterisation of 'left' and 'right', in operational terms.
As for 'Trumpthink', I need more thought and analysis before venturing an essay.
"I'd be interested in others' characterisation of 'left' and 'right', in operational terms."
Q: What do : USSR, E.Germany, Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Romania, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia, Albania, Mongolia, plus a dozen or so African nations over the years... all have in common?
A: All former socialist states.
Today, only China, Cuba, Laos, Vietnam and N. Korea remain, and China and Vietnam are arguably socialist in name only, while N. Korea is some kind of weird personality cult.
THIS was a very interesting desertation... yes Trump is definitely carrying out a revolution in the US foreign policy... USAID being the example... and THANK GOD for that... Skeletons are falling out of the cubbards... so the revolution is at home too... and good.. that it is a revolution who would know better than a Russian ))).
Re Greenland ... me being Danish... all up to the Greenlanders... time to get their independence from colonial Denmark... and from there well Greenland and USA will come to some understanding ... a new era for Greenland... full of both good and bad... no doubt many lessons to learn.
Re. Europe, GOD HELP US.... anyway God helps those who help themselves... so better times for Europe will not be tomorrow and possibly not in my lifetime (I am 84)... We need some courageous NEW leaders to dismantle EU and NATO... each of the European nations can then take the decisions best for them... Germany and France will possibly be at each other's throats as they always were...
Germany will no doubt winn as France lost their extra income from the vasals in Africa.... but thats for another day...
How will the 3 superpowers get along ... No there wont be a military war China vs USA... there will be trade wars... The best the 3 can do is agree on Spheres of Influence... and each one make their own Sphere as prosperous as they can...
Thanks a lot Karloff for publishing the desertation done by someone who really know his subject....
What passed for the combined west has only a single plan, the WEF/Davos/Bilderberg reset via techno feudalism. As there is no other plan and the pendulum swings against them we'll have more Trumps with erroneous policies that may provide psychological relief for supporters but result in continued deterioration. Both sides may double down on failure, and then we'll reach the point of outright hostilities with violence.
demoRats destroyed scAmerica, but at least ScKamala Harris could not steal the election.
But she stole my Grasshopper taxi business forevermore, and gave me solitary isolation when I ran for mayor against Gruesome Gavin Gruesome Newsom. Jail was my reward.
In fact America is mostly a jail .
I don't see anyone smiling, but the indoctrinated hatred of all things Russian. Has not ceased.
Thank you for all your fine work.
I noticed a while back that the so-called protests are staged and scripted ...
The evidence is simple, there has not been even one protest against the American war against Russia in these fascist states
I mean, America is killing me, but maybe that is what twas all about, the dammm hokey pokey.....
Canadian Trump Supporters: You Are a Threat to This Country
This is a post from Liz Cheney. I wish I had written it b,ut I didn't. I'm not sure I could have said it better.
It frames the danger and real threat that Canadians who support Trump's takeover of Canada as the 51st State.
It's more than a Precautionary Take. It's a Dire Warning
“There’s no sugarcoating it anymore. If you support Donald Trump—especially as a Canadian—you are a direct threat to this country. Not just an embarrassment, not just misinformed, but a genuine threat to Canada’s democracy, stability, and future.
This isn’t a debate about left vs. right. It’s about whether you stand with democracy or with a wannabe dictator who is dismantling it in real-time
Trump Is a Danger to Canada—And So Are You
Let’s be clear about what Donald Trump means for Canada:
• Trade & Economy: Trump has already proven he’s willing to rip up trade deals, slap tariffs on Canadian goods, and treat this country like an economic punching bag. His second term will be worse. He wants to exploit Canada, not work with us.
• Right-Wing Extremism: Trump emboldens the most dangerous, radical elements of society—white supremacists, conspiracy theorists, and violent extremists. We saw it with the Freedom Convoy, which had direct ties to American far-right groups. Supporting Trump means welcoming that extremism into Canada.
• Attack on Sovereignty: Trump has openly treated Canada as weak and disposable. If given the chance, he would force our government into submission, demand loyalty to his agenda, and strip us of our independence.
So when a Canadian proudly declares they support Trump over any Canadian leader, what they’re really saying is:
✔️ They would rather see this country controlled by a foreign dictator than governed by Canadians.
✔️ They support the rise of authoritarianism over the principles of democracy.
✔️ They would rather burn this country to the ground than see a government they don’t like in power.
That’s not patriotism. That’s treasonous thinking.
Double the Threat: Canadian Trump Supporters Are Worse Than American Ones
It’s bad enough when Americans fall for Trump’s lies. But when Canadians do it? That’s next-level delusion.
At least in the U.S., Trump voters are dealing with their own country’s fate. Canadians who support Trump are betraying their own country’s interests to cheer for an authoritarian who couldn’t care less if Canada collapsed.
These people aren’t “conservatives.” They’re not “free thinkers.” They’re useful idiots for an anti-democratic movement that would destroy Canada without a second thought.
Time to Call It What It Is
We need to stop treating Canadian Trump supporters as just misinformed or misguided. They are actively choosing to support a fascist movement that threatens everything this country stands for.
They are a risk to our democracy. They are a risk to our sovereignty. They are a risk to our safety.
And we will call them out at every turn. Because when democracy is at stake, silence is not an option.
What Greenland is doing , should also be done in Canada. Canada is being threatened . THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES AND HIS ADMINISTRATION are enforcing Tariffs Threatening Canadas Economic Sovereignty and is against USMC Trade Agreements. The United States President and Administration is threatening ANNEXATION OF CANADA. Which is a Threat to Canadas Sovereignty and NATIONAL SECURITY. The President of the United States and Administration is backing CANADIAN PROGRESSIVE CONSERVATIVE PARTY. Promoting separation of Alberta Canada. A threat to CANADIAN SOVEREIGNTY AND TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY.
BRICS AND BRI will give us more Sovereignty, and no longer have to depend on WRC for Trade , we can use our own CURRENCY with other Countries within BRICS or WRC if we choose. MILITARILY we can Procure Equipment from other Countries and not rely on the U.S MIC. BRICS allows Countries to settle their own Affairs without Interference,Regime Changes or Military Interventions. But with Diplomacy. We would no longer worry about Tariffs,Annexation,Financial (WRC) Sanctions (USA). Because there’s more In the World other than the USA.
You're right, those are all things we *could* do. But we won't, because the vast majority of Canadians will suffer great economic hardship if we choose to reverse our dependency on America.
People will talk about patriotism and history and independence, but in the end they will choose to preserve their economy first. The choice is between dependent prosperity and sovereign usury. That's what the USA offers: prosperity through dependency. This is the Faustian deal that Canadians made long ago and still abide by today.
The question I ask my fellow Canadians is what kind of sovereignty do you think the country has? Canada is economically dependent on the US for everything except maple syrup. Our government walks in lockstep with Washington, our security is their security, there is no made-in-Canada foreign policy, and our culture is overwhelmed by our neighbour to the south. In fact, since the last wake-up call during the first Trump presidency, Canada didn't diversify but instead increased its economic dependency on America.
Canadians are like little sleeping piggies, sucking on the sow's teats. We don't want to be independent, we just want the milk to keep flowing. Trump woke the piggies up, but if the milk flows again we will go right back to sleep.
This shows the Russian commentariat to be very clear eyed about Trump and his policies. In the late nineteenth century the US was a rising industrial power, now it is a declining post-industrial power. The next four years will turn into a somewhat unplanned imperial retreat, as the inability of the US to better China and split it from Russia becomes evident.
The world that faces the next president in 2029 will be quite a different one.
The aspirations people had about America’s New World has been left out so I think the intellectual focus here is seriously misguided as to what is going on with humanity .
It’s talk as if the living doesn’t exist and humanity is simply a pawn to be used.
If Vasily Kashin's analysis seems to me interesting and in certain aspects clarifying, your commentary on it seems even more interesting. From it I extract two quotes that I consider significant:
(1) “The forever wars that were sparked by the 911 false flag have bankrupted the federal government, although they’ve certainly aided the Zionists who helped plan it.”
The weight of Zionism in the domestic and foreign policy of the Outlaw US Empire has been and remains decisive. The support of the powerful lobby for Trump is not unconditional, nor does it have MAGA politics as a priority. The lobby will do everything in its power to establish the priorities of the Empire according to its own interests.
(2) “What Europe needs is a return of “left” political parties to confront the EU-Globalists: There’s plenty of room for a Nationalist Left to fill the current political vacuum.”
One of the main missions entrusted to the CIA after the Second World War was precisely the destruction of the European left, specifically its then powerful communist parties, most of which were pro-Soviet. In Spain, but especially in Italy, this clandestine anti-communist struggle reached authentic terrorist levels on the part of the CIA. Today we can see that it was not so much about fighting communism as about keeping Europe separated from the USSR, that is, from Russia.
The problem of the Outlaw US Empire is the same, or similar, to that of a huge oil tanker: both to dock and to set sail properly, the tanker needs the support of tugboats to support and correct the force of its enormous inertia. These "tugboats" are called Diplomacy and reliability: the Outlaw US Empire has lost both.
Thak you for your excellent work, Karl.
"the world's best geographical location, a huge domestic market, high resource endowments, developed industry and the world's largest technological potential."
Only the second item is true. But is worthless if that domestic market can't afford even the basics.
The third is correct; high but not huge compared to Russia for example.
The last two are not correct at all.
Yeah, I didn’t want to call him out on too many of his errs. I see the Canadians are standing up and pushing back as well. Many of those resources are gone, extracted already. And as with the 1890s Plutocrats, today’s have no need for industry when their rents pay so much.
"Yeah, I didn’t want to call him out on too many of his errs"
Yeah, I'm a picky bastard. But we have to be as factually wrong statements sometimes stick and are repeated as fact forever.
Yes, I’d be stricter on a Russian site.
Very interesting and informative.
For some time I've been struggling to understand what is meant by 'left' and 'right' in governance.
'Left', for me, means comprehensive welfare government. A government entrusted with providing welfare for all its people: ensuring that everyone, whether individual, in family, community, or distinctive social sector receives what they need to live well, and isn't deprived of any of these goods. This is not impossible. In Britain after the war we built a welfare state through public services, which has only been demolished through neoliberal Thatcher's reign. China has built it over the past 40-odd years years. The ideological manifesto of left is based on "Help each other out, don't do each other down". Internationally pursuing mutual sovereign respect, cooperation and friendliness. Unfortunately disregarding sovereign internal ethnofascist social institutions of inequality. National evils are none of our business.
'Right', I find more difficult to comprehend. It seems to follow the injunction: "fight each other". Divide and rule so that the identified distinctive social group strives to win against the excluded rest. It embodies ethnofascism: we, the privileged people, rule, punish (corporally and capitally), and deprive you, the unworthy. And we practice 'keep-rule'. National Securities R Us.
In national and international behaviour, 'right' comprises the intention and practise of mortal belligerence of the putative ruling group towards everybody else. Wherever in the world mutualist, socialist governance has emerged and been effective, the Anglo-American Imperialists have destroyed it, more than 50 times since the Second World War. Recently, it seems, mutualist governance has begun surviving the viral rabidity of rightist global forces.
I'd be interested in others' characterisation of 'left' and 'right', in operational terms.
As for 'Trumpthink', I need more thought and analysis before venturing an essay.
"I'd be interested in others' characterisation of 'left' and 'right', in operational terms."
Q: What do : USSR, E.Germany, Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Romania, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia, Albania, Mongolia, plus a dozen or so African nations over the years... all have in common?
A: All former socialist states.
Today, only China, Cuba, Laos, Vietnam and N. Korea remain, and China and Vietnam are arguably socialist in name only, while N. Korea is some kind of weird personality cult.
Doesn't that tell you something about socialism?
THIS was a very interesting desertation... yes Trump is definitely carrying out a revolution in the US foreign policy... USAID being the example... and THANK GOD for that... Skeletons are falling out of the cubbards... so the revolution is at home too... and good.. that it is a revolution who would know better than a Russian ))).
Re Greenland ... me being Danish... all up to the Greenlanders... time to get their independence from colonial Denmark... and from there well Greenland and USA will come to some understanding ... a new era for Greenland... full of both good and bad... no doubt many lessons to learn.
Re. Europe, GOD HELP US.... anyway God helps those who help themselves... so better times for Europe will not be tomorrow and possibly not in my lifetime (I am 84)... We need some courageous NEW leaders to dismantle EU and NATO... each of the European nations can then take the decisions best for them... Germany and France will possibly be at each other's throats as they always were...
Germany will no doubt winn as France lost their extra income from the vasals in Africa.... but thats for another day...
How will the 3 superpowers get along ... No there wont be a military war China vs USA... there will be trade wars... The best the 3 can do is agree on Spheres of Influence... and each one make their own Sphere as prosperous as they can...
Thanks a lot Karloff for publishing the desertation done by someone who really know his subject....
what a treat.
What passed for the combined west has only a single plan, the WEF/Davos/Bilderberg reset via techno feudalism. As there is no other plan and the pendulum swings against them we'll have more Trumps with erroneous policies that may provide psychological relief for supporters but result in continued deterioration. Both sides may double down on failure, and then we'll reach the point of outright hostilities with violence.
A fascinating analysis. And it's not just Europe that could use a return of actual 'left' political parties.
demoRats destroyed scAmerica, but at least ScKamala Harris could not steal the election.
But she stole my Grasshopper taxi business forevermore, and gave me solitary isolation when I ran for mayor against Gruesome Gavin Gruesome Newsom. Jail was my reward.
In fact America is mostly a jail .
I don't see anyone smiling, but the indoctrinated hatred of all things Russian. Has not ceased.
Thank you for all your fine work.
I noticed a while back that the so-called protests are staged and scripted ...
The evidence is simple, there has not been even one protest against the American war against Russia in these fascist states
I mean, America is killing me, but maybe that is what twas all about, the dammm hokey pokey.....
In the US, the more things change, the more they stay the same
I stand with Canada. Fighting Trump to keep CANADA’S Sovereignty,National Security and Territorial Integrity is a BIGGER PRIORITY then UKRAINE
https://substack.com/@calluramichael491850/note/c-98516938?r=1ii73h&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action
Canadian Trump Supporters: You Are a Threat to This Country
This is a post from Liz Cheney. I wish I had written it b,ut I didn't. I'm not sure I could have said it better.
It frames the danger and real threat that Canadians who support Trump's takeover of Canada as the 51st State.
It's more than a Precautionary Take. It's a Dire Warning
“There’s no sugarcoating it anymore. If you support Donald Trump—especially as a Canadian—you are a direct threat to this country. Not just an embarrassment, not just misinformed, but a genuine threat to Canada’s democracy, stability, and future.
This isn’t a debate about left vs. right. It’s about whether you stand with democracy or with a wannabe dictator who is dismantling it in real-time
Trump Is a Danger to Canada—And So Are You
Let’s be clear about what Donald Trump means for Canada:
• Trade & Economy: Trump has already proven he’s willing to rip up trade deals, slap tariffs on Canadian goods, and treat this country like an economic punching bag. His second term will be worse. He wants to exploit Canada, not work with us.
• Right-Wing Extremism: Trump emboldens the most dangerous, radical elements of society—white supremacists, conspiracy theorists, and violent extremists. We saw it with the Freedom Convoy, which had direct ties to American far-right groups. Supporting Trump means welcoming that extremism into Canada.
• Attack on Sovereignty: Trump has openly treated Canada as weak and disposable. If given the chance, he would force our government into submission, demand loyalty to his agenda, and strip us of our independence.
So when a Canadian proudly declares they support Trump over any Canadian leader, what they’re really saying is:
✔️ They would rather see this country controlled by a foreign dictator than governed by Canadians.
✔️ They support the rise of authoritarianism over the principles of democracy.
✔️ They would rather burn this country to the ground than see a government they don’t like in power.
That’s not patriotism. That’s treasonous thinking.
Double the Threat: Canadian Trump Supporters Are Worse Than American Ones
It’s bad enough when Americans fall for Trump’s lies. But when Canadians do it? That’s next-level delusion.
At least in the U.S., Trump voters are dealing with their own country’s fate. Canadians who support Trump are betraying their own country’s interests to cheer for an authoritarian who couldn’t care less if Canada collapsed.
These people aren’t “conservatives.” They’re not “free thinkers.” They’re useful idiots for an anti-democratic movement that would destroy Canada without a second thought.
Time to Call It What It Is
We need to stop treating Canadian Trump supporters as just misinformed or misguided. They are actively choosing to support a fascist movement that threatens everything this country stands for.
They are a risk to our democracy. They are a risk to our sovereignty. They are a risk to our safety.
And we will call them out at every turn. Because when democracy is at stake, silence is not an option.
What Greenland is doing , should also be done in Canada. Canada is being threatened . THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES AND HIS ADMINISTRATION are enforcing Tariffs Threatening Canadas Economic Sovereignty and is against USMC Trade Agreements. The United States President and Administration is threatening ANNEXATION OF CANADA. Which is a Threat to Canadas Sovereignty and NATIONAL SECURITY. The President of the United States and Administration is backing CANADIAN PROGRESSIVE CONSERVATIVE PARTY. Promoting separation of Alberta Canada. A threat to CANADIAN SOVEREIGNTY AND TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY.
https://substack.com/@calluramichael491850/note/c-97854975?r=1ii73h&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action
https://substack.com/@calluramichael491850/note/c-97854975?r=1ii73h&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action
BRICS AND BRI will give us more Sovereignty, and no longer have to depend on WRC for Trade , we can use our own CURRENCY with other Countries within BRICS or WRC if we choose. MILITARILY we can Procure Equipment from other Countries and not rely on the U.S MIC. BRICS allows Countries to settle their own Affairs without Interference,Regime Changes or Military Interventions. But with Diplomacy. We would no longer worry about Tariffs,Annexation,Financial (WRC) Sanctions (USA). Because there’s more In the World other than the USA.
You're right, those are all things we *could* do. But we won't, because the vast majority of Canadians will suffer great economic hardship if we choose to reverse our dependency on America.
People will talk about patriotism and history and independence, but in the end they will choose to preserve their economy first. The choice is between dependent prosperity and sovereign usury. That's what the USA offers: prosperity through dependency. This is the Faustian deal that Canadians made long ago and still abide by today.
The question I ask my fellow Canadians is what kind of sovereignty do you think the country has? Canada is economically dependent on the US for everything except maple syrup. Our government walks in lockstep with Washington, our security is their security, there is no made-in-Canada foreign policy, and our culture is overwhelmed by our neighbour to the south. In fact, since the last wake-up call during the first Trump presidency, Canada didn't diversify but instead increased its economic dependency on America.
Canadians are like little sleeping piggies, sucking on the sow's teats. We don't want to be independent, we just want the milk to keep flowing. Trump woke the piggies up, but if the milk flows again we will go right back to sleep.
Regarding the interaction between Trump's Outlaw US Empire and Europe, you may like the first article I translated from Italian here: https://geopolitiq.substack.com/p/the-trump-tornado-makes-the-eu-drop
The second one deals with so-called Trump's "warnography". I think you may like both.
This shows the Russian commentariat to be very clear eyed about Trump and his policies. In the late nineteenth century the US was a rising industrial power, now it is a declining post-industrial power. The next four years will turn into a somewhat unplanned imperial retreat, as the inability of the US to better China and split it from Russia becomes evident.
The world that faces the next president in 2029 will be quite a different one.
A fascinating and clear-eyed perspective from Mr. Kashin. Thanks Karl!
The aspirations people had about America’s New World has been left out so I think the intellectual focus here is seriously misguided as to what is going on with humanity .
It’s talk as if the living doesn’t exist and humanity is simply a pawn to be used.